Diocese of Caledonia priest fired ‘without cause’


Brenda Still

Former bishop-elect of Caledonia and rector of the Parish of Bulkley Valley Jacob Worley has been terminated effective November 30. Photo: Contributed

The Rev. Jacob Worley, whose election as bishop of the diocese of Caledonia was not upheld by the provincial House of Bishops in May, has been fired from his position as a priest effective November 30, 2017.

The termination was made “without cause,” according to a statement released by diocesan administrator, the Rev. Gwen Andrews.

Andrews declined to make further comments, but wrote in the statement that the decision was made by Archbishop John Privett, metropolitan (senior bishop) of the ecclesiastical province of British Columbia and Yukon, “in consultation with those in leadership positions in the Diocese and in prayerful consideration of what is in the best interests of the Worley family and the future of the Diocese.”

Worley could not be reached for comment. But in an interview with The Anglican Planet, Worley said he received notice of his termination on Friday, November 10 in a letter and phone call from Privett. According to The Anglican Planet, Worley asked what the reason was for his termination, but Privett declined to give him one.

In a telephone interview with the Anglican Journal, Privett stated that he made the decision, as he has episcopal authority during a vacancy, but that he “did not act alone,” rather in consultation with the diocesan leadership. Privett declined to speak further about the reasons behind the termination, saying, “I don’t think it’s appropriate to speak about personnel matters. Those are confidential.

“What I can say, though, is that it was not precipitous. I thought about it carefully, I discussed it with others, and I do believe the decision was in the best interests of both the diocese and the Worley family.”

Privett says the diocese is “looking into” the details of Worley’s immigration status, as they were unaware of the details of his residency before making their decision.

“I can say, we don’t want to create hardship for the Worley family, so we’re trying to act as compassionately as possible.”

Worley’s termination “is accompanied with a generous severance package to assist Rev. Worley and his family in the transition,” the diocese’s official statement reads.

It also says that “the details surrounding the [Worleys] residence status in Canada were unknown but will now be considered.” Worley is American.

According to The Anglican Planet, Worley’s residency in Canada is contingent on his employment, and he and his family will have to leave the country within 10 days of the last day of his employment.

Worley, who until his termination was rector of the Parish of Bulkley Valley, was elected bishop of Caledonia earlier this year. However, he was not consecrated as bishop, after a ruling by the House of Bishops of the ecclesiastical province of British Columbia and Yukon. The bishops said their decision was based on Worley’s involvement with the Anglican Mission in America (AMiA), a grouping of theologically conservative churches that was originally a mission of the Anglican Province of Rwanda. According to the bishops, Worley’s involvement with a church plant in the geographical jurisdiction of The Episcopal Church was made without the permission of The Episcopal Church. This violates Resolution 72 of the 1998 Lambeth Conference, according to the bishops, who objected to Worley’s election on the grounds that he “teaches or holds, or within five years previously taught or held, anything contrary to the Doctrine of Discipline of the Anglican Church of Canada.”

A new election was held in late October, and the Rev. David Lehmann was elected bishop.

When asked about the reaction to the news of Worley’s dismissal, Privett said he hasn’t heard much from the diocese, but knows there are “a few individuals who are annoyed and upset.”

The Anglican Communion Alliance (ACA), an organization of lay and clergy that according to its website “affirms classical Anglicanism within the Anglican Church of Canada,” has responded with a statement, which reads in part, “we are deeply concerned for both the wellbeing of Worley and his family, and the rebuilding of trust within that diocese.”

The statement was issued by Sharon Dewey Hetke, national director of the ACA and author of the interview with Worley published by The Anglican Planet.

“Last May, many Canadian Anglicans were dismayed by the sloppy procedural path that led to the Provincial [House of Bishops’] majority decision rejecting Caledonia’s choice of Worley for bishop,” the statement reads. It asserts that Worley “asked how he could be acceptable as a priest but not a bishop” and was told he was a priest in good standing. “This standing has not been revoked and so Worley and others have expressed shock at last week’s firing in the interim between local diocesan bishops.”

Hetke’s statement questions “the motivations behind” Worley’s dismissal and “whether or not traditionally-minded clergy can count on fair treatment.”

It expresses the hope that Privett “will be able to bring more clarity to this situation.”

Privett also said he was “somewhat surprised” to see an interview with Worley in The Anglican Planet. The Anglican Planet is not a publication of the Anglican Church of Canada.

In the interview with the The Anglican Planet, which reportedly took place in May but was published November 10, Worley said that the House of Bishops “couldn’t accept me as a bishop because I planted a church within the boundaries of the Episcopal Church in the diocese of the Rio Grande, and that I won’t say I’m sorry I did it,” adding that he felt he could not apologize for the church because “the Lord moved in a mighty way there.”

In response to these statements, Privett said, “That was news to me when I saw that article. I mean, he’s free to make his own statements, but our decision was made before that statement.”

Editor’s note:  A quote from Archbishop John Privett should have read, “I don’t think it’s appropriate to speak about personnel matters. Those are confidential.” An earlier version of the story used the word “personal,” instead of “personnel.” 

Related Posts

Joelle Kidd

Joelle Kidd

Joelle Kidd joined the Anglican Journal in 2017 as staff writer. She has worked as an editor and writer for the Winnipeg-based Fanfare Magazine Group and as freelance copy editor for Naida Communications.

4 Responses

  1. It is my understanding that Rev. Jake has asked repeatedly for the reasoning behind the decision the PHOB made and how they came to their final conclusion. I believe he has also asked why he is the only Bishop elect in Canada to ever be denied and have that Canon applied to him when there are at least 3 Bishops in BC and several across Canada that were in violation of the same Canon at their election. He has asked these questions of Privett privately and on at least two occasions publicly, thereby foregoing any expectation from Rev. Jake of confidentiality. Privett just continues to not answer the question.

    And really!~ why does it matter that Rev. Worley had an interview with The Anglican Planet? Are Anglican Priests in Canada only allowed to make comments to the Anglican Journal? When did you makeup that Rule?

  2. From the article:
    Privett says the diocese is “looking into” the details of Worley’s immigration status, as they were unaware of the details of his residency before making their decision.

    This comes across to me as a threat. To publically bring into question a person’s immigration status is a serious accusation that has real potential to cause the individual hardship with the Government of Canada. Yet Privett says “I don’t think it’s appropriate to speak about personal matters. Those are confidential.” A person’s immigration status is a very personal matter and Privett seems to have no problem with talking publically about it.

    For Privett to then go on and say “I can say, we don’t want to create hardship for the Worley family, so we’re trying to act as compassionately as possible.” seems hypocritical.

  3. I would like to ask the wider Anglican Church to pray for the Dicese of Caledonia. By the time newly elected Bishop David Lehman takes his post in January it will have been vacant for more than a year. I find all the controversy about our first election for Bishop and now the firing of Rev Jake Worley has not done our Diocese any good. Since the first election we have lost two priest and now with the firing of Rev Jake Worley that makes it three and there were already a few places without priest before all this. I find there are a lot of questions as to why this all happened and I don’t find this has done anything to unify us. It leaves myself with questions about how we operate as Anglicans and treat one another. I don’t know how anyone can thing this is best for the Worley family. It’s winter and almost advent. It’s suppose to be a time of joy and celebration as we await the birth of Christ. I find my heart filled with sadness and lack of understanding why firing a man without explanation can turn out to be good for our Diocese. Please pray for the Diocese of Caledonia as we try to navigate through all of this. I can only hope and pray that this does not scare new priests away for fear that the same thing could happen to them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email
Share on print